10 tips for grilling the perfect steak!

  • Walton's Employee

    Steak on the Grill

    Learn these 10 tips for grilling a great steak!

    Hi guys, I had some close friends over recently and I fired up the grill to cook a few KC Strip Steaks for everyone, other than my wife who is a Communist, whoops, sorry I meant Vegetarian! One of my friends told me that steaks from my grill always seem to taste better. Since flattery will get you everywhere with me and they are friends I told them everything I do to a steak before during and after cooking it. All of my tips seemed very basic to me, things I just assumed most people did but they had either never heard of some of them or thought they were old wives tales. I decided to check with some other friends and family outside of this building, since most of us have been in this business long enough that we are meat snobs! I was surprised to find out that most of what I was talking about was not common knowledge even amongst people I consider to be very good cooks. So here are just a few tips to make your next dinner party or BBQ a hit!

    Nice Marbling

    #1 Not all Steak are equal
    If you are buying your steaks at a grocery store the person grabbing them for you is usually not the butcher, they are just help that got assigned there for their shift and they probably know as much about choosing a steak as I do about Nuclear Fusion. Don’t be afraid to ask for specific steaks or to ask for a closer look at a specific steak. What you are looking for is a nice even marbling of fat throughout the entire steak, this is going to give you a nice tender cooked steak.

    #2 Let the steaks warm up!
    Take your steaks out of the refrigerator 45 minutes before they go on the grill so they can warm up. A cold steak on a hot grill is a recipe for a tough as leather disaster of a steak!

    #3 Consider Tenderizing
    If you purchased a steak that did not have good marbling on it or has other imperfections consider tenderizing it with a mallet or even a Jaccard meat tenderizer. Tenderizing a steak works by damaging the collagen and connective tissues to make the texture and taste of the steak better. If you have purchased a great steak there is no need to do this.

    #4 Ultimate Steak and Roast Rub
    This isn’t one that everyone would know but Excalibur’s Ultimate Steak and Roast Rub is the best thing to put on steaks! It is pretty much the only seasoning we put on steak anymore and I’ve tried everything from just salt and pepper to a hazel nut coffee rub, which was better than it sounds. Ultimate Steak and Roast Rub is our bestselling shaker for a good reason and is something you should add to your pantry for any steaks but also for veggies and salads.

    Reverse Seared Steak

    #5 Reverse Sear!
    I cannot say this enough, Reverse Searing is the best way to cook your steak. It gives you a perfect cook throughout the entire steak and still gives you that nice crust.

    #6 Only flip once
    You do not want to flip your steaks often, the less you flip it the more juice your steaks will retain. Also flip it with tongs or a spatula, DO NOT pierce your steak to flip it. If you are reverse searing then this tip only applies to the final searing portion.

    #7 Butter is your friend
    You need to start putting a dollop of butter on each side of your steak as it is finishing up on the grill. A lot of people like cooking their steak in a pan with butter if they are cooking inside on a stove. The issue with that is butter has a low smoke point and you are going to want to get to some temperatures well above that, so put the butter on the top side and let it melt down over the steak instead!

    #8 Pull up short of your target
    The most commonly ordered steak is medium rare so unless specifically told otherwise that is what I aim for. Like Hank Hill said, if someone asks me for a well done steak I politely ask them to leave my house! The correct temperature range for medium rare is 130° to 135° so I make sure to never go above 130° as they are going to continue to cook another few degrees after you take them off of the grill.

    #9 Re-Season
    After you pull your steaks off of the grill hit them with some more seasoning, most of what you have on there before you put them on the grill is lost during the cooking process, so make sure to at least hit them with some more salt and pepper.

    #10 Let them rest
    There are differing opinions on the effectiveness of napping your steaks. Some people say there is no proof that it has any real effect. I don’t care what anyone says, I know it makes a difference when I let my steaks sit for 2-3 minutes before serving them. Just do it trust me on this!

    So there are 10 easy things you can do to have your friends drooling anything time you are grilling for them!

    Shop waltonsinc.com for Broil King Grills

    Shop waltonsinc.com for Steak Seasonings

    Shop waltonsinc.com for Thermometers

    Shop waltonsinc.com for BBQ Acessories

    Shop waltonsinc.com for Tenderizers

    Steak and Roast Rub

    Excalibur's Ultimate Steak and Roast Rub

    Jaccard Tenderizer

    Slap Tenderizer

  • Regular Contributors

    Reverse Sear is absolutely the way to go… I am looking forward to trying Sous Vide, they tell me it’s every bit as good and easier to control…

  • Sous Vide is the only way we cook steaks. There is no more perfect way to get the proper internal temperatures in a fine ribeye. Put meat in a zipper bag full of seasonings, and squeeze out the air.
    Even a tough ribeye is tenderized by leaving it in the controlled water temperature a little longer.
    1 hour for a USDA prime, 2 for choice and 3 for grass fed at 129 degrees.
    We finish the steaks in a hot cast iron skillet with some bacon and sausage drippings left over from breakfast. Zero grey meat under the surface of the steak.

Log in to reply

Recent Posts

  • M

    @parksider Thanks for the follow up!! I was really watching the internal temperature when they were in the rolling (HOT) water and making sure to pull them right at the 165. And then right into the ice water bath.

    read more
  • You guys got a great job! Im pretty passionate about this kinda stuff. I enjoy it a lot and love doing R and D stuff! Keep up the fun work!

    read more
  • P

    @Jonathon Yes Jonathon-it’s in your head 🙂
    @mikeihuntr My only advice is to keep the water around 170F, not a rolling boil. If the casing are too tight they WILL explode then you have a really big pot of bad soup! A nice simmer is the way to go, take them out 155-160 and into a water bath. Here is a pic, we just use the turkey fryer with the basket. It makes it really easy to remove from the water and rinse. I will also recommend keeping a temp probe right in the meat you can see the wire going into the water. Good luck!!

    0_1548289087099_19MM bologna in water bath.jpg

    read more
  • P

    This was a big topic of conversation because we do freeze/thaw/process/refreeze venison and pork, never an issue. As a former restaurateur and certified food handler here is what Dept of Agriculture has to say. I’ll defer to the experts:

    Author: Alice Henneman, MS, RDN

    The U. S. Dept. of Agriculture (USDA) advises:

    Once food is thawed in the refrigerator, it is safe to refreeze it without cooking, although there may be a loss of quality due to the moisture lost through thawing. After cooking raw foods which were previously frozen, it is safe to freeze the cooked foods. If previously cooked foods are thawed in the refrigerator, you may refreeze the unused portion. Freeze leftovers within 3-4 days. Do not refreeze any foods left outside the refrigerator longer than 2 hours; 1 hour in temperatures above 90 °F.

    If you purchase previously frozen meat, poultry or fish at a retail store, you can refreeze if it has been handled properly, according to USDA.

    DO NOT thaw meat at room temperature, such as on the kitchen counter.

    Safety will depend on whether the raw product was handled properly before it was frozen, refrozen shortly after it was thawed, cooked to a safe temperature when it is eaten and handled safely if there are any leftovers.

    read more
  • K

    What temperature should I pull my cured and smoked bacon out of my smokehouse?

    read more
  • P

    @jonathon it is printed on the Box. I’m looking for a bag that has a evoh barrier. Does Waltons carry a four or five mm evoh High barrier bag?

    read more

Recent Topics

Popular Topics





Looks like your connection to Waltons Community was lost, please wait while we try to reconnect.